In "Colette And The Mystery Girl," Belle and Sebastian & Lisa Helps The Blind trace a crush that curdles from infatuation into weary indifference. The allure of the art school mystery girl collapses when she turns out to be a fake, and even Colette's pop music advice feels like a shallow shortcut to being liked. The repeated shrug about not knowing or caring flattens every possibility, including the half-hearted offer to just be friends. That final line, where friendship already sounds like an ending, captures the quiet relief of letting a disappointing connection go.
Colette And The Mystery Girl Lyrics by Belle and Sebastian & Lisa Helps The Blind
In my mind, there’s nothing between the two of them
One is called Colette, but the other, she’s such a mystery
She goes to the art school
Next time I saw her, I will take a chance with her
Do you spend your day waiting for something to happen?
Give yourself a shake, nothing is going to happen on its own
Just red bills and blue days
Next time I saw her, then I realized she was a fake
I made a big mistake
I don’t really know
I don’t have an opinion on anything
You could cut your hair
I will probably like you just the same
I don’t really care
I don’t listen to what the kids have to say
We could just be friends
Maybe that would be better in the end
So I asked Colette “What kind of music should I play?”
She said “If you don’t play pop, then you will be unpopular
Don’t think too hard about it”
Next time I saw her, she was on the front of Marie Claire
She had dyed her hair
I don’t really know (I don’t really know)
And I don’t really care (I don’t really care at all)
We could just be friends (I think we’re just be friends)
This feels like the end
