One Hand in the Cookie Jar Lyrics by Sara Berki
Comin’ home with the collar of your pearl snap smelling like No. 5
Said you weren’t gonna be home late, but I’ve been watching the clock all night
You could’ve done a better job at covering up what you’re tryna hide
Pirate Red all through your beard, you found yourself a late night delight
With one hand in the cookie jar and the other holding me tonight
Sneaking ‘round and playing me, I should of made you sleep outside
But I can’t stand to be alone, baby, won’t you just let me know
Why you got one hand in that cookie jar and the other on my heart
Layin’ awake staring at the ceiling tryna find myself some sleep
You ain’t even half aware that I know you’re cheating on me
Saw Bethany down at the store and she said she had some tea
She said “I saw them getting it on last night, down at Lee Harvey’s”
With one hand in the cookie jar and the other holding me tonight
Sneaking ‘round and playing me, I should of made you sleep outside
But I can’t stand to be alone, baby, won’t you just let me know
Why you got one hand in that cookie jar and the other on my heart
You had one hand in the cookie jar and the other holding me tonight
Sneaking ‘round and playing me, I should of made you sleep outside
But I can’t stand to be alone, baby, won’t you just let me know
Why you got one hand in that cookie jar and the other on my heart
Just take that hand out from the jar or take it off my heart